This webmaster thinks that the U.S. Department of Homeland Security has gotten too large to secure the homeland.
Once upon a time, a fashionable ancedote that us right wingers told each other was that the Federal government was so large and its numerous parts so disconnected from each other that, on the one hand, it maintained an official proclamation that smoking was bad, and spent oodles of money to convince people not to smoke, and on the other hand, it handed out agricultural subsidies to tobacco farmers. Because the latter does not exist anymore, this example is no longer valid, but the Feds keep coming up with ways to contradict itself.
This time, the paradox is entirely contained in the Homeland Security cabinet department. At least with the tobacco question above, the objects of interest and spending weren’t under the same department, they were split between Health and Human Services for the former, and the Agriculture Dep’t for the latter.
As we all know, Hurricanes Katrina and Rita have forced untold thousands of people from their homes and into shelters or other temporary accommodations. In earnest, some forward-thinking computer geeks are coordinating efforts to hook shelters up with computers and online access. At the website , one can find out that older and otherwise jettisoned and dust-gathering computer equipment can be donated to shelters, and a special bootable CD-ROM that will load a Linux OS Distro straight into the Firefox browser with a special Katrina-themed home page will run just fine on these systems, in contrast to resource-hog Windows XP. (Of course, that’s missing the point that Microsoft would still charge $100 a piece to install one copy of XP on one computer.) As one can see, the website coordinates hardware donations and has links to downloadable files so that anyone can download the .iso file, burn it onto a CD-R, so it can be used at the shelter web stations (or anywhere else, for that matter).
Fine, as far as that goes. But imagine you’re someone driven out of New Orleans or environs, and you’re staying in a shelter in, say, the Dallas, Texas area. You sit at one of these computers, surf the internet using this bootable CD-ROM, ergo you’re surfing with the Firefox browser. Then you log onto the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) website, and follow its links so that you can apply for emergency FEMA assistance.
You’ll get one of those friendly error messages that you need to run Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 for Windows XP Service Pack 2 (IE ver 6.00.2900) in order to fill out an online application for aid. Otherwise, they give you a FEMA toll-free phone number to call to apply, and give you a web link to download IE 6 for XP SP2 if you want to take the online route. Be mindful of the fact that IE won’t run on Linux, and at that, IE6-XP2 won’t run on any Windows version older than XP SP2, and the computer you’re sitting in front of might not have a hard drive to download anything into, as boot-from-CD setups don’t need one.
How’s that for a good swift kick in the nads?
Now, FEMA is within the Homeland Security department, at least it has been since HLS became a cabinet-level agency. HLS also has another appendage, called the US-CERT (United States Computer Emergency Readiness Team) . In June 2004, US-CERT issued an official proclamation the the Microsoft Internet Explorer browser was too great of a security risk, and considering how many Osamas and Omars out there with broadband would love to cripple America by unleashing digital terrorism, and considering how the almost ubiquitous use of attack-susceptible IE was the terrorists’ turn key for such a plan, that they advised people to switch from IE to a more secure alternative, like Firefox or Opera, for their day-to-day browsing.
(As an aside, if you haven’t done that yet, the graphical hyperlink buttons at the bottom of this frame are your first step to doing so.)
So, what do we have here? Within one single cabinet-level department, the one supposedly responsible for protecting us from all the evil in the world, one of its arms is telling us that Internet Explorer is too dangerous and shouldn’t be used, and another one of its arms is requiring Internet Explorer if victims of a natural evil want to apply for Federal assistance.
All this drives me so bonkers that I’m tempted to take up smoking.