The following is an open letter to those of you who play football for any of the high schools in the P.H.L. (Public High League, i.e. St. Louis City). Specifically, this refers to Beaumont, Career Academy, Cleveland NJROTC, Gateway Tech, Roosevelt, Soldan, Sumner and Vashon. If you fit in that category, you will want to read this letter, and perhaps print it out so that everyone else on the team can as well.
I found out, by watching KSDK-TV’s news several days before the writing of this letter, that football fields and facilities at P.H.L. schools are in deplorable shape. Among other problems, the playing fields are full of rocks, glass, bricks and litter, the locker rooms are dilapidated, the showers are filthy, the spectator bleachers are structurally unsafe, and certain playing and practice equipment is old, substandard, worn-out, and in some cases non-existent.
A group of people decided that this was unconscionable, and have taken the initiative and organized themselves into a non-profit organization, called P.H.L., Inc., in order to raise money and coordinate volunteers who will make all the necessary repairs and purchase and donate the necessary equipment to rectify these problems. At the organization’s website, one can see the some progress they have already made at some of your schools, and see what else needs to be done.
I’m glad for them, and I’m glad for all of you.
But all of these things makes one collective group of people look bad. That is the St. Louis City Public Schools administration. Here’s why I say that.
For the 2004-05 School Year, the total budget for the St. Louis City Public Schools, in terms of spending per student, was $10,357, and total spending overall was $443 million.
Compare this to some of your competition in St. Louis County. For the sake of fairness, I will not compare apples to oranges, in that I will only compare the St. Louis City Public Schools to County districts that have multiple high schools under its aegis. Therefore, I will not compare St. Louis City to Kirkwood or Webster Groves, for both of those districts only have one high school in each.
The Parkway district, which contains Parkway Fern Ridge, Parkway North, Parkway South, Parkway Central and Parkway West High Schools, spent $9,063 per student and about $220 million overall in 2004-05.
The Rockwood district, which contains Eureka, Lafayette, Marquette and Summit High Schools, spent $7,389 per student and about $224 million overall that same year.
The Hazelwood district, which contains Hazelwoods East, Central and West High Schools, spent $7,774 per student and about $181 million overall that same year.
The source for all of these figures is a spreadsheet downloaded from the website of the Missouri State Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. The spreadsheet requires Microsoft Excel; if you need a program that can read Microsoft Excel files, Click Here. Alternatively, you may download the same spreadsheet in Open Document Spreadsheet format (.ods), viewable in OpenOffice.org and KOffice, directly from this website. The spreadsheet uses vague acronyms on the top column, this text file shows what they stand for.
All of this means that your schools have more money than their schools, definitely more in terms of money per student, and about twice as much (if not more) for a yearly overall budget. Not only does your St. Louis City district spend more per student than these other three districts, but since it has far more students than the others, its total budget is far higher. In the field of economics, there is this concept called economies of scale. To explain fully the concept would take up the space of an entire term paper, but basically what it means is that larger and richer institutions are able to do things better and more cost-efficiently and more time-efficiently than smaller similar institutions. Applying that to you, this means your facilities and equipment ought to be BETTER than your counterparts in the Rockwood, Hazelwood and Parkway districts.
Obviously, it is not that way.
Somehow, the men and women who are entrusted to run your schools, who are entrusted with significantly more money than districts with schools that have far better football facilities and equipment than yours, don’t seem to have two nickels to rub together to keep your football infrastructure in anything better than a deplorable condition.
While we’re all glad that P.H.L. Inc. exists and are doing what they are doing, it is not their fundamental responsibility to do so. That duty belongs to the people who spent $443 million overall and $10,357 per student on your behalf last school year.
As an aside, I have found out on the spreadsheet I downloaded that, as late as several school years ago, the St. Louis City Public Schools spent over $500 million overall and about $11,400 per student. Between then and now, budget cuts in earnest of revenue shortfalls were made, but City Schools spending is still high. If your football infrastructure in 2002 was good but degraded for the sake of neglect from then until now, it might be understandable. But the truth of the matter is that even then, these problems you experience firsthand existed. The neglect has existed for quite a long time, notwithstanding the budgetary ebbs and flows of the City District.
If I were you, I would say something about it. The squeakiest wheel is the first to get greased, and perhaps you would do well for yourselves to start squeaking. http://www.slps.org, or 801 North 11th Street (The Daniel Schlafly Building) is where to squeak.